Which murder mystery game is best?
Which murder mystery game is best for your group?
The best murder mystery game depends on the story your group wants to investigate. In the UK shop, The Brenham Murders and The Cult are the two cases currently available to buy. Compare their themes below before choosing your next case file.
How to choose a case
Start with the story that interests your group most. Both cases let you work through a shared investigation without assigning roles. Read each product description for the latest details before you buy. Additional titles marked “coming soon” are not included in this comparison because they are not currently available to purchase.
How we compare these games
The cases are ordered by their average customer rating across all countries. A rating follows the same case even when its name differs by language or market. This is an ARKIV guide, not an independent product test. Check each product page for current contents, age guidance and availability.
Compare UK murder mystery games
The Brenham Murders
A standalone murder investigation and a natural first case for a group.
The Cult - The One True Path
Choose this case if your group is drawn to a darker story about a secretive community.
Frequently asked questions
Can two people play a murder mystery game?
Yes. Two players can examine the same evidence and discuss their theories together.
Do we need a game master?
No. Nobody needs to know the solution in advance.
Is this like an escape room at home?
Both involve solving problems, but an ARKIV case focuses on analysing evidence in a fictional criminal investigation rather than completing a chain of separate codes.
How does an ARKIV case work?
You examine witness statements, photographs and other evidence, discuss possible explanations and reveal the solution once you have reached a conclusion. Everyone can investigate together; no game master is required.
Explore all UK cases